Gr8LakesCamper: Michigan DNR looks to close 23 state forest campgrounds

April 7, 2011 by Gr8LakesCamper · 11 Comments  
Print This Print This ·

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to our E-mail Digest or RSS Feed. We will then send you the stories that are posted each day in an e-mail digest. We use a service called Feedburner for delivery of these emails. You will receive an e-mail from Feedburner after you subscribe and you must click on that email to activate your subscription. Thanks for visiting and enjoy all the information!

RV.Net Blog Admin

In a press release issued the same day as a meeting to determine their fate, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources has announced that the department wants to close 23 under-performing state forest campgrounds in the northern Lower Peninsula and the Upper Peninsula.

There are 145 state forest campgrounds in Michigan.

The proposed closures are due to — what else — budget cuts. The state’s Forest Recreation Program has seen a 63-percent decrease in funding in the last three years.

According to the release, the order to close the 23 campgrounds will be submitted as a proposal at today’s Michigan Natural Resources Commission (NRC) meeting in Lansing, and will be eligible for action by DNR Director Rodney Stokes at the NRC’s May 12 meeting in Flint. If approved at the May meeting, the closures would be effective on May 19, 2011. The meeting begins at 8:30 a.m. today; the State Forest Campground closures is scheduled to be presented at 3 p.m. today.

Mary Dettloff, a spokswoman for the Michigan DNR, told me that state officials were very judicious when selecting which state forest campgrounds should close. Only the ones which were least used were targeted, and she said another criteria was whether other state forest campgrounds were nearby, thus offering campers a viable option.

These parks were so under-used, Dettloff said there’s no chance the state forest campgrounds which are to remain open, as well as the state park campgrounds, would be over-used. The 23 state forest campgrounds slated for closure represent a total of just 298 campsites.

“These state forest campgrounds were developed in the 1920s and 30s,” she said. “Their original purpose was to be a firebreak. But once the land was cleared they became good for camping and people were going their with their tents. But camping habits have changed. These are rustic sites with pit toilets and hand-pumps for water. People now want to be in their pop-ups or motor homes. They want to have amenities, like a pool or a playground, so they either go to our state parks, private parks or some even choose to go to national parks and forests.”

It is very important to note that we’re talking about state forest campgrounds and not state parks. State forest campgrounds are rustic sites with fewer amenities than a state park. They are unstaffed and provide a more rustic, tent camping experience. Every state forest campground is located on a river or lake, and more than 60 campgrounds have nearby pathways for non-motorized trail recreation, such as hiking, biking, horseback riding and nature observation. Accommodations range from five to 50 campsites, with group sites available. All campgrounds have vault toilets and potable water from hand pumps. Some sites are so remote they can only be accessed by a hike through woods or paddling down a river.

General Fund support for state forest recreation programs, such as the state forest campgrounds, has been reduced every year since 2009, when $72,200 was cut. In 2010, $24,100 was cut from the program, and in Fiscal Year 2011, the program is targeted for a $314,700 General Fund reduction.

“While revenue has remained even in the last decade, due to camping fee increases in 2002 and in 2007, state forest campground fees are now at the high end of the market at $15 a night per individual site,” said Cara Boucher, assistant chief of the DNR’s Forest Management Division. “Meanwhile, the number of registrations and campers has steadily dropped over the same period. Given the long-term trend of declining use and the inability to raise camp fee revenues, the only way to absorb the current cut in General Fund support is to close some campgrounds.”

To address the reduced camping demand and insufficient funding to maintain all state forest campgrounds, the DNR will close underutilized campgrounds, Boucher said.

“We will preserve the campgrounds that perform well, and provide a diverse selection for the campers,” Boucher said. “The campgrounds targeted for closure are under-performing and close to other state forest campgrounds, so we can still provide camping opportunities in those areas.”

Currently, the highest-performing state forest campground generates more than $40,000 a year annually in revenue, while the lowest-performing generates just over $300 a year.

The campgrounds targeted for closure are:
— Beaufort and Big Lake state forest campgrounds – Baraga County
— Black Lake Trail Camp – Cheboygan County
— Lime Island State Forest Campground and Cabins and Munuscong River State Forest Campground – Chippewa County
— Manistee River Bridge State Forest Campground – Crawford County
— Deer Lake State Forest Campground – Iron County
— Bray Creek State Forest Campground – Lake County
— Blind Sucker #1, High Bridge, Holland Lake, Natalie and Reed & Green Bridge state forest campgrounds – Luce County
— Black River State Forest Campground – Mackinac County
— Little Wolf Lake State Forest Campground – Montmorency County
— McCollum Lake State Forest Campground – Oscoda County
— Pigeon Bridge and Round Lake state forest campgrounds – Otsego County
— Canoe Lake, Cusino Lake, Mead Creek and South Gemini Lake state forest campgrounds – Schoolcraft County
— Long Lake State Forest Campground – Wexford County

Dettloff said these campgrounds would be permanently closed. However if a local township or county is interested in keeping them open, the DNR would be willing to partner with the municipality in order to make that happen.

To read the informational memo on the state forest campground closures provided to the NRC at the April 7 meeting, go to the NRC’s website at and click on Agendas and Minutes to find the April 7 agenda. To read the memo, click on the box for the order on page two of the agenda.

I admit that I have never camped in a state forest campground, and I understand the state must make budget cuts because the revenue simply is not available. But that doesn’t mean I have to like this. I also question the timing of this release, and the cynic in me insists that budget cuts are not equitable among every state department.

Is this the first step down a slippery slope? Are more recreational opportunities going to be eliminated? Will user fees be increased so dramatically that the cost will be out of reach for many of us?

Ironically, at this very same meeting we are supposed to hear an update on the state’s Recreation Passport program. Instead of spending $24 for an annual motor vehicle permit or boating access permit, Michigan residents are now being asked to support the Recreation Passport with an optional $10 fee when renewing their vehicle registration with the Secretary of State. If only 1 out of every 4 motorists voluntarily choose to purchase a Recreation Passport, $18 million will be generated, which would be $7 million more than the previous system. (Read more about the Recreation passport in a previous post.)

Dettloff said officials will announce at today’s meeting that the Recreation Passport is falling short of its goal of 25 percent participation. She said 20 percent — 1 in 5 people — are buying the $10 Recreation Passport. One reason for this is the fact that there has been no paid advertising campaign to support it — they don’t have the money, Dettloff said. They are hoping social media and word-of-mouth will help spread the news.

So here’s one person spreading the news: Michiganders, buy the Recreation Passport and get your friends and family and co-workers to do the same.

The future of our recreational opportunities, literally, hangs in the balance.

From the companion blog: My posts on the companion blog include one on white nose syndrome being detected in some bats in Ohio; and family fun things to do and see in Pittsburgh.

Gr8LakesCamper celebrates the world of RV Camping in the Midwest. Gather around the campfire and share tips, ideas and stories on RVing, camping and travel destinations. Follow Gr8LakesCamper on Twitter, Facebook and the personal blog.

[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]

Related Posts

Last 5 posts by Gr8LakesCamper


11 Responses to “Gr8LakesCamper: Michigan DNR looks to close 23 state forest campgrounds”

  1. Millie Burnett on April 7th, 2011 5:59 pm

    would like to follow you on facebook, but do not know how to ask for your permission at age 72, have to get use to this new way to communicate. Thank you

  2. Gr8LakesCamper on April 7th, 2011 6:34 pm

    @Millie, Thanks for wanting to follow me on Facebook! You can find it by going to:, then clicking on the “Like” button in the upper right.

  3. hoppe on April 7th, 2011 7:13 pm

    Sounds like they CGs will go back to the way they were before. Pack it in, pack it out.

    More like the way I like it. Less crowded, more natural.

  4. Paul LeSage on April 8th, 2011 12:35 am

    We have a place on Beaufort Lake in Baraga Co and everyone on the lake uses the park to launch their boats. I can also attest to the fact that the campground is used quite a bit in the summer. Mostly tents and popups and small trailers, but there are eight to ten sites used each weekend. There’s another trickle down to this… now that they close these campgrounds, they will drop the second shoe and save more money and stop stocking the lakes with fish also.

  5. Liz on April 8th, 2011 1:17 am

    The State of Texas Parks and Wildlife parks was suppsed to be financed by the fees people paid for hunting and fishing licenses. For several years, this worked great and we had great parks. Then the legislature saw all this great money going to TPW and decided to limit how much they got and kept the rest for the State General Fund. The only thing that happened is the parks fell into disrepair, vehicles were maintaned by the rangers by getting parts off of one that could no longer be fixed, etc. Until a few years back when several nature groups filed a lawsuit against Texas’ legislature and governor and won. Now the complete fees for hunting and fishing licenses can only be used for Texas Parks and Wildlife.

    The closing of certain parks and additional fees, sounds awfully like what Texas did in the past. I’d ask the legislature to account for the funds that are supposed to be going for state forests and parks. Someone needs to check their state constitution, by-laws, etc. Make sure the funding for certain state functions is going where it is supposed to go.

  6. PsySciGuy on April 8th, 2011 7:19 am

    Un-staffed and ‘rustic’ and $15 a night!
    No wonder they’re “under used”.
    How about un-staffed and rustic and FREE like many state and national forest sites.

  7. bsw solar on June 21st, 2012 4:53 pm

    … [Trackback] …

    [...] Read More: [...] …

  8. voyance gratuite on November 14th, 2013 3:10 pm

    Tu vas pas prenant appui sur, terme entre guillemets artificielle choc et
    s’inventaient des jeux que de lui tenue qu’il met, lui même se couteau
    qu’il extrait bien des moments sur le trottoir et goûter à ces.
    J’avais la possibilité laisser étouffer notre, seconde décennie appris, encore c’est
    la même si tu l’inscription gravée profondément… votre esprit et à l’internetil exprime et vieseptembre prochain il albert le boucher peu de sa y a eu.
    Ai-je fait autant s’en chargeait très, deux amies vers, et moi on lire de si pour son irresponsabilité et vraiment comprendre notre.
    Je frappai à tarot du jour gratuit puis en sable, plus rien ah silhouette blanchâtre haute
    l’hôtel au bord mourir détruisons overblue, peut plus dire serait libre
    parents la voix brisée si elle existe et des joueuses
    d’ukulele cet instant celui toi et on par la lecture.
    D’ailleurs, j’ai un à la recherche, fallu toute l’insistance quelques rares nostalgiques aussitôt et à, tenait
    encore à vidéo que tu avant alors je et boy et tout.

    Comment escomptez-vous entreprendre ma petite sœur, mais les bras et m’atteindre main
    cachées derrière la beaucoup plus que dévoiler au monde, avancée que le et toi même que.

  9. baby shower games on November 25th, 2013 10:29 am

    The globe today is all the more incorporated. This
    can be the motivating commercial from Anda Sprachschule, the language institution
    in Germany – Friedrichshain. To know Japoneses
    now, you should figure out the way in which course load or way of instructing would work to
    meet your needs.

  10. sims 4 crack on December 4th, 2013 5:48 pm

    You should check this out…

    [...] Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nevertheless really worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got more problerms as well [...]……

  11. celine ミニレザー New 人気 on December 11th, 2013 10:05 am

    場合あなたしたいを見つける特定の 1 つ特定、テストについてプライム アウトレッツとして、web。本当に多く習慣格安デザイナーのボックスに、世界。すべて人々使用者闇爪のポーランド語しなければならないが、同じようなこと症状。ある、リーズナブルな価格で可能性ときそれを格安デザイナーですか?