Top

Tire and Wheel Balance: A Lost Art?

September 22, 2008 by Robert Henderson · 6 Comments  
Print This Print This ·

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to our E-mail Digest or RSS Feed. We will then send you the stories that are posted each day in an e-mail digest. We use a service called Feedburner for delivery of these emails. You will receive an e-mail from Feedburner after you subscribe and you must click on that email to activate your subscription. Thanks for visiting and enjoy all the information!

RV.Net Blog Admin

Tire and wheel balance is something most of us don’t think about, until it causes a vibration or shaking in the coach that gets your attention. The problem is, a lot of shops just put your wheels and tires on a machine, spin them up, then bolt them onto your coach without knowing if the assembly is going to be smooth on the vehicle.

Tire/wheel vibration can be caused by two things: an out of balance condition, and/or an out of round condition. If we suspect that the tire is out of balance, we put it in our tire balance machine and check them out. It’s important to understand that not all tire machines are created equal, and not all tire technicians do things the same way. Variations in the way the wheel is chucked up in the machine versus the way it mounts on the coach can cause inaccurate readings; in other words, just because the balance machine says it’s balanced, doesn’t mean it will be on the coach. We’ve tried several tire balancing machines, and they’re not all accurate.

Back in the old days, the best way to determine tire balance was by spinning them up to highway speeds on the vehicle using another machine we have. We now have a tire balancing machine that has proven itself to be accurate, but when it doubt, we can still spin the tire/wheel assembly up on the vehicle as fast as 70-90 mph depending on the size of the assembly. This spinning machine is still very valuable to us when we are trying to diagnose unique problems. For example, we had a customer come in a while back whose coach was vibrating so badly, his refrigerator stopped working. He had the tires balanced more than once  at another shop. It was only until we spun the assembly up while mounted on the coach that we found out the brake drums were out of balance. In that case, we balanced the wheels right on the coach with our strobe light balancer to offset the drum imbalance. That’s the way we always used to do it, but it is very time consuming-sometimes 45 minutes to balance one tire on a large vehicle.

Out of round tires can cause major problems, too. How do you tell the difference between out of balance and out of round vibrations? Generally speaking, with out of balance tires, the faster you go, the worse it shakes. With out of round tires, it will usually shake worse at a certain speed, and then you can eventually drive through it…but it could be a very high speed before it goes away. Sometimes, you can actually see if the rear tires are out of round by lifting the rear axle of the vehicle, putting the transmission in gear at idle, and watch them turn from behind. For less obvious cases, we’ll use a dial indicator to determine the run-out of a tire, and see if it is within specs for the given tire and tire diameter. Very seldom are tires perfectly round, so you have to know the specs of the tire you’re working on.

If the tire wasn’t mounted properly last time, it may not be properly seated on the bead, which will cause the tire to be out of round. This is an important thing to take into consideration before having the tires “trued”(where a special lathe is used to take the high spots off of a tire) to make them round again; if the tire is not properly seated, and you have it “trued”, you’ll end up ruining the tire. Sometimes, it may be necessary to mount and dismount the tire several times to make sure.

In other cases, the problem is caused by bad wheels; if the wheel isn’t round, it’s going to affect the tire and how it works. An alloy wheel like an Alcoa is more concentric than a stamped steel wheel. You’ll notice that more expensive cars always have alloy wheels, and this is not just for looks. It’s a rounder wheel, so there is less problems with out of round conditions, and less road harshness. Some people have had success with “automatic” tire balancers, such as the products offered by companies like Balance Masters, but we still believe that you need to have a round tire and wheel balanced properly in the first place. That means mounted up properly, with a round tire and a round wheel. If the wheel or tire is out of round, you’re just trying to compensate for it with an automatic balancing system.

I would like to end this post by paying tribute to an industry icon and friend to us all, Gaylord Maxwell, who passed away over the weekend. Gaylord had a real passion for the industry, and we have a great deal of respect for him and all of the things he did for RVers. Over the years, I have done tons of seminars at different events, but I have never seen anything like the education and training that was available at Life On Wheels conferences. Gaylord truly cared about educating RVers about so many different aspects of life on the road, from technical subject matter and safety to making a living while full-timing. Whatever you wanted to learn, he and his crew could teach you. We were grateful for his friendship, kindness, and to be invited to be part of his conferences. They have a great group of instructors and I truly hope they will continue Gaylord’s teachings for many years to come. Our prayers are with Gaylord’s wife, Margie, their family and friends, Peggy Waterman and all the rest of the wonderful people at Life On Wheels.

 

 

 

[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]

Related Posts

Last 5 posts by Robert Henderson


Comments

6 Responses to “Tire and Wheel Balance: A Lost Art?”

  1. Don on September 23rd, 2008 9:23 pm

    I’ve had wheel balance troubles with my 2000 Ford F53 20,500lb chassis since I took delivery. While it was under warranty, the Motorhome Assistance center sent me 125 miles to the closest dealer to my home equipped and willing to work on my class A chassis. This dealer performed TSB 00-21-9 – twice! Once I left the MH there for 3 weeks while they replaced two wheels and 3 tires. After a trip, I returned the MH to them telling them it still wasn’t right. This time they had it for over 4 weeks during which they condemned 3 more tires and waited on Goodyear to deliver 5 more tires – two tires failed the tests on the Hunter GSP 9700 Vibration Control System when they were delivered. Family matters prevented me from following up on this problem for two years. When I got frustrated with the continued vibration I felt, I called Haweka to find out if anyone closer to me had an adapter plate for the GSP 9700. I found one at a Ford dealer within 6 miles of my home. While they would not work on a class A chassis, they did agree to check the tires/wheels if I took them off and carried them in. They condemned 4 more tires. The cost out the door for their services and the new tires was over $2200. The problem continues today.

    My MH has a tag axle increasing the chassis capacity to 22,000lbs. I’ve discovered that by swapping sides with the tag axle drums, I can change the location of the vibration. I now blame the tag axle drums for my continued problems. I’ve tried Centramatic balancers with no effect on the tag axle. The next thing to try is either like you suggest with a spin balancer or replacing the hub/drum assembly on the tag axle or trying to have it balanced locally at a machine shop. The spin balance sounds like the cheapest way out.

    Thanks for covering this topic – now to find a good service location that still has a spin balance capable of checking a 19.5 tire/wheel.

  2. Robert on September 25th, 2008 9:35 pm

    Hello Don,

    Vibration problems can make you crazy for sure! We have had a fair of vibration problems with Ford F-53 chassis. For a while we getting coaches in the shop with “three” sides to a tire. This is where tire truing really comes in handy.
    I agree with you about the drums. We may be able to find one of our dealers in your area who can help you. Best wishes and thank you for your post.

    I

  3. John Fleming on January 25th, 2010 2:43 pm

    I came across this article and while it looks dated I thought it was worth taking a minute to let someone know that if there are folks in the area of Western Pennsylvania who are experiencing vibration issues that we offer vibration resolution service on motorhomes and buses and we absolutely guarantee satisfaction. We are a family owned company, been in business since 1955 and we know how to fix these problems once and for all. We have references too.

  4. Darrell on August 4th, 2010 4:33 pm

    pleas contact me.

  5. עיצוב גינות on June 27th, 2012 4:27 am

    … [Trackback] …

    [...] Read More: blog.rv.net/2008/09/tire-and-wheel-balance-a-lost-art/ [...] …

  6. Nitrogen Tyre Inflation on July 11th, 2012 11:03 am

    This is really informative. We should not neglect this kind of things. Tires are the only part of the car that touches the road that is why we must always check on its condition before driving.

Bottom